AI Vendor Due Diligence Checklist for a Small Business

Updated 8 min read

An AI vendor due diligence checklist for a small business should scale with what the tool touches. A tool that sees no personal data needs three questions: the three-year cost, how you leave, and who answers the phone. A tool that sees client or staff records adds five contract questions. A tool wired into your systems adds proof of security.

Most published checklists run to 30 or 47 questions and were written for procurement teams. A 12-person firm will not answer 47 questions, so it answers none. This guide gives you the short version and the reasoning behind each question.

How much due diligence does an AI tool actually need?

An AI tool needs due diligence in proportion to the damage it could do if the supplier failed or leaked data. The NCSC’s supplier assurance guidance says controls should be proportionate to the risk. It gives small firms no tiers, so this guide supplies them.

Sort every tool into one of three tiers before you read a single sales page.

TierWhat the tool touchesQuestions to askExample
1Nothing personal or confidential3 (cost, exit, support)A tool that drafts social posts from public information
2Client, staff or applicant records8 (tier 1 plus 5 contract questions)A call recorder or CV screener
3Your live systems, or acts for you12 (tier 2 plus 4 security questions)An assistant connected to your email, CRM or accounts package

Bedrock AI’s view is that most small firms over-check tier 1 tools and under-check tier 3 tools. The tools that feel harmless, such as a free note taker, often sit in tier 2 the moment someone records a client call.

What three questions apply to every AI vendor?

Every AI vendor owes you a clear answer on cost over three years, how you leave, and who supports you. These three cost nothing to ask and they filter out a surprising number of suppliers. Ask them in writing and keep the replies.

  1. What will this cost over 36 months, all in? Ask for seat price, set-up fee, training, extra usage charges and the renewal uplift.
  2. How do I leave? Ask what format you can export your data in, how long the export takes and what happens to your data afterwards.
  3. Who do I contact when it breaks, and how fast do they answer? A named person or a support address with a stated response time counts. “Community forum” does not.

Here is why the first one matters. Take a made-up tool at £25 per seat per month for 8 staff. That is £200 a month and £7,200 over three years before any set-up.

Add 20 hours of staff time to roll it out at £30 an hour and the figure reaches £7,800. If the tool saves 12 hours a month at the same rate (£360), it pays for itself in under two years.

Our AI ROI calculator guide shows how to cost an hour properly. All figures in this example are illustrative.

Which five contract questions apply when the tool sees personal data?

Five questions apply once a tool handles personal data. Each maps to a term UK GDPR Article 28 already requires in your supplier contract.

The ICO lists what a processor contract must include. You do not need to memorise it. Check the contract covers these five points.

  1. Does the vendor act only on your instructions? The ICO says a processor may handle personal data only on the controller’s documented instructions. This is the point that should stop a vendor training its models on your clients’ records without asking you.
  2. Which other companies see the data? The ICO says a processor cannot engage another processor without your written authorisation. Ask for the sub-processor list and how you hear about changes.
  3. What happens to the data when the contract ends? The ICO says the processor must delete or return all personal data at your choice. Ask how long deletion takes, including backups.
  4. Will the vendor help if there is a breach or a request from a client? The ICO lists help with breach notification and with individuals’ rights requests as required terms.
  5. Can you check their claims? The ICO says the processor must supply the information needed to show compliance and allow audits. For a small firm this usually means asking for written answers and any certificates.

If the vendor’s standard terms do not cover these five points, ask them to add the clauses. A vendor that refuses has told you something useful before you have paid anything.

Our guide to keeping company data out of AI model training goes deeper on question one. It explains the gap between a no-training promise and zero retention.

What four security questions apply when the tool connects to your systems?

Four security questions apply when an AI tool can read or change your email, accounts or customer records. A weakness at the supplier then becomes a weakness in your business. Ask for evidence rather than reassurance.

  1. Does the vendor hold Cyber Essentials? The NCSC describes Cyber Essentials as the minimum standard of cyber security the government recommends. It checks five controls: firewalls, secure configuration, update management, user access control and malware protection. Anyone can verify a certificate through the IASME certificate search. The NCSC says certification starts at £320 plus VAT as of October 2026.
  2. What can the tool access, and can you limit it? Ask for the exact permissions it needs. A tool that wants full mailbox access to summarise one folder is asking for too much.
  3. Who at the vendor can see your data? Ask whether staff can read your content and under what conditions.
  4. How will you hear about a breach, and how quickly? The NCSC’s guidance covers incident management and the 72-hour GDPR breach window. Ask for the answer in the contract, not on a web page.

For tools at this tier, the NCSC’s supplier assurance questions cover ten areas, from governance to exit terms. Pick the three or four that match your tool rather than sending all of them.

What should you check about the company behind the tool?

Check that the company behind the tool exists and has traded long enough to survive your contract. Our guide to hiring an AI consultant lists the Companies House and ICO fee register checks. The same checks work for a software supplier and take five minutes.

Two more checks matter for software. First, ask what happens to your account if the company is bought or closes.

Second, check how long it has existed. Many AI tools are under two years old, so a three-year contract with a young supplier is a bet on its survival.

Should you test the tool before you sign?

Test any tier 2 or 3 tool on your own real work before you sign. A demo shows the supplier’s best case, not yours.

Ask for a trial of 2-4 weeks using your own documents with personal details removed. Our vendor proof of concept framework sets out what each week should prove.

Agree the pass mark before the trial starts. For example: “The tool must draft 8 out of 10 file notes that need no more than two minutes of editing.” Without a pass mark, the trial ends with a feeling, and feelings favour the salesperson.

This is the diagnose-first step. Before you compare tools, work out which job you want done and what it costs you now. If you cannot name the job, no checklist will save you from buying the wrong tool.

What are the red flags in an AI vendor’s answers?

The clearest red flags are answers that dodge the question, refuse to put terms in writing, or rest on a badge you cannot verify. A good vendor answers a tier 1 question in a sentence and a tier 3 question in a document. Watch for these patterns.

  • “We take security very seriously” with no certificate, report or named control. Ask for the certificate number.
  • Exit terms that only appear after you cancel. Data export should be described before you sign.
  • A price quoted per seat with usage charges “as needed”. Ask for a cap.
  • A refusal to list sub-processors. The ICO says you are entitled to authorise them.
  • Pressure to sign this week. A tool worth buying is worth buying after a two-week trial.

Keep every answer in one folder with the date. If the tool causes trouble later, that folder is your evidence of what you were promised.

FAQ

How long should AI vendor due diligence take for a small business? Due diligence takes about 30 minutes for a tier 1 tool and half a day for a tier 3 tool. Most of that time is waiting for written answers from the vendor. Set a deadline of five working days for replies.

Do I need a data processing agreement with an AI vendor? You need a written contract covering the Article 28 terms whenever the vendor handles personal data for you. Many vendors publish a standard data processing addendum you can accept or negotiate. Check it covers instructions, sub-processors, deletion, breach help and audits.

Is Cyber Essentials enough proof that an AI vendor is secure? Cyber Essentials proves a vendor meets a government baseline on five basic controls. It does not test how the vendor handles AI model training, retention or staff access to your content. Treat the certificate as one answer among several.

How often should I review an AI vendor after I sign? Review each AI vendor once a year and whenever it adds a new AI feature, changes sub-processors or has a breach. A feature that starts reading new data can move a tool up a tier. Keep the dated answers folder and update it each time.

What if the vendor will not answer my questions? A vendor that will not answer written questions before you pay will not answer them after you pay. Note the refusal and move to the next supplier. For a tier 2 or 3 tool, treat it as a reason not to buy.


Get ahead with AI by getting The Business Brain | Would rather talk it through? Book a free 15-minute call

Keep reading

More for owners

All articles
Recruitment AI CV Screening: Is It Legal for a Small Business? AI CV screening is legal in the UK if a person really considers each applicant. What the ICO's 2026 report means for a small firm, and when to skip it. / 8 min AI risk assessment AI Risk Assessment Template for a Small Business An AI risk assessment template for a small firm: five questions, a 1-3 score and a clear approval rule, with three use cases scored in full. / 8 min AI policy AI Acceptable Use Policy: What a Small Firm Needs An AI acceptable use policy for a small business fits on one page: approved tools, a data traffic light, a human check and eight clauses you can copy. / 7 min
Book a free call